April 2011
Upside Down
Hello baseball world, I hope you’ve all been well. I just wanted to briefly discuss the American League Central, seeing as it’s the division that I pay the most attention to. Is anyone else baffled by the standings as of today?
1. Cleveland Indians: 13-8
2. Detroit Tigers: 12-10
3. Kansas City: 12-10
4. Minnesota: 9-12
5. Chicago White Sox: 8-14
Now it makes sense that the Tigers are quickly moving up the standings, but how weird is it to see Kansas City and Cleveland still hanging in there. Now, I’m sure the final standings won’t look like this at years end, but as a Detroit fan, I’m pleased to see them having a winning record, despite their inconsistencies.
I remember reading an interview with White Sox GM Ken Williams in the preseason saying something along the lines of ‘If we don’t sell seats this year, we’re going to lose a lot of money.’ Call me crazy, but they aren’t winning, and that sure makes selling seats difficult. Ozzie needs to have another one of his annual blowups with the media, or else this season could prove to be both long and expensive for the White Sox.
I Want This, Not That!
As promised, here comes my answers to my last blog, where you’re stuck between two similar players, but you can only have one or the other. Here’s my picks, along with a brief explanation as to why I chose them.
1. Miguel Cabrera or Albert Pujols
I had to go with Miguel Cabrera, but I’ll admit it took some mulling over. Cabrera is younger, and that was ultimately the biggest factor. If Pujols can stay healthy, he’ll continue to be the force that he’s been throughout his career. I don’t see either being a ‘wrong’ answer though, since both are MVP caliber players.
2. Justin Verlander or Tim Lincecum
The hardest part for me to choose between Verlander and Lincecum is what do I think of their futures. Both have proven to be dominant aces for their respective teams, and neither has shown any ability to slow down. I’ll take the extra experience, and take Verlander by a very small margin.
3. Adrian Beltre or Alex Rodriguez
Despite all of his off the field distractions, I do think you have to go with Alex Rodriguez. Rodriguez has been a significantly more career hitter throughout his career, and has a lot more playoff and big game experience. That, and Beltre just always seems angry when he’s playing, so I’ll take the more jovial A-Rod.
4. Robinson Cano or Chase Utley
Cano has been quietly becoming one of the most offensively productive second basemen in MLB history. Not only is he playing well, he’s arguably playing in the hardest city, too. I do like a lot of things that Utley brings to the table, but ultimately I think Cano brings a little bit more.
5. Adrian Gonzalez or Joey Votto
I’m going to go slightly against convention, and I’ll go with Joey Votto. Really, there’s no reason to think that his 2010 MVP season was a fluke, and with a better lineup to protect him, it’s not hard to believe his numbers won’t improve. I do think Gonzalez will put up quality numbers in Boston, but I really do like the prospect of Votto becoming better in time.
6. Brian Wilson or Jonathon Papelbon
I’m pretty sure it’s impossible to not like Brian Wilson, unless you’re not a fan of awesome things. He’s a quality closer and a fan favorite. Nothing against Papelbon, but I think any dream team needs to have some personality, and Wilson comes with plenty of that.
7. Kurt Suzuki or Joe Mauer
I think this was one of the easiest pairings, but there’s a reason I put it. First of all, I’d take Mauer. The guy is a tremendously talented hitter, and seems to be nothing but a professional at all times. The reason I would be tempted to pick Suzuki instead, is due to the fact that there are a lot of people in baseball who wonder how long Mauer will be able to catch. If he becomes an outfielder for instance, I think Mauer loses a lot of value as a player. With that being said, he’s still catching, so he’s still my pick.
8. Vladimir Guerrero or Johnny Damon
I go with Vlad the Impaler here, out of the fact that I think he has more left in the tank than Damon. Both provide a lot of clubhouse presence and veteran leadership, but I think having Vladimir in your lineup will make you more likely to win.
9. Ichiro Suzuki or Jayson Werth
Despite being older, I have to go with Ichiro. I like Werth a lot, so it’s not an attack against him, but Ichiro has year in and year out been one of the most consistent hitters within the last 10 years. As long as Ichiro still has his legs underneath him, it really does seem like there’s no slowing him down. I might have gone with Werth, but he really doesn’t have a proven enough track record for me to take him.
This or That?
I was talking with some people the other day about some hypothetical situations. It’s a game I enjoy playing, so I thought I would share it with you. The rules are quite simple. I give you two options, and you pick one or the other. Imagine you’re a GM of a team (either fantasy or an actual MLB team) and you’re stuck picking one player or the other. With all of these, assume their salary is not an option. Tomorrow night I’ll post my selections along with why, but I’m curious who you all would pick.
1. Miguel Cabrera or Albert Pujols
2. Justin Verlander or Tim Lincecum
3. Adrian Beltre or Alex Rodriguez
4. Robinson Cano or Chase Utley
5. Adrian Gonzalez or Joey Votto
6. Brian Wilson or Jonathon Papelbon
7. Kurt Suzuki or Joe Mauer
8. Vladimir Guerrero or Johnny Damon
9. Ichiro Suzuki or Jayson Werth
Walk This Way
This one will be admittedly short and sweet since I have to wake up in a few hours, but it is moments like this that make me love the fact I have season tickets. Definitely a big momentum shift for the Tigers who desperately need it.
What’s a Penny Worth?
Today with no doubt will be a big game for the Detroit Tigers and Brad Penny. After having two disappointing starts, there are a lot of questions as to whether or not he’s still a pitcher worth keeping around. I’m curious to see how he handles a rather difficult Texas lineup, but hopefully he can at least put together a quality start.
And as promised, here’s the current 2011 Tigers PPA% updated through 4/11/2011
(Sorted by number of PA)
Miguel Cabrera:. 512
Austin Jackson: .262
Victor Martinez: .262
Will Rhymes: .316
Jhonny Peralta: .429
Brandon Inge: .273
Brennan Boesch: .424
Alex Avila: .355
Magglio Ordonez: .346
Ryan Raburn: .375
Don Kelly: .250
Ramon Santiago: .400
Casper Wells: .333
Coke’s No Joke
Pardon the cheesy title, but I felt the need to comment on Phil Coke’s first start for the Detroit Tigers. Although many questioned whether or not he could make the adjustment going from the bullpen to the starting rotation, Coke put Tigers fans at ease with his performance today.
Granted, it wasn’t exactly against an offensive powerhouse, but 6.2 innings, three hits, two runs along with seven strikeouts should silence many critics. Now, this isn’t to say that Coke was perfect today, and certainly his four walks were higher than you would like to see, but his ability to mix pitches and speeds was encouraging.
The Tigers definitely need to see productive outings out of Coke if they want to contend in 2011, and this is definitely a step in the right direction.
Manny Being Manny?
I’ll admit, I’ve always considered myself entertained by Manny Ramirez,
although not necessarily a fan, I find his sudden retirement to be
nothing less short of Manny-esque.
According to an article at ESPN,
Ramirez has reportedly decided to retire, rather than deal with MLB’s
Joint
Drug Prevention and Treatment Program. Until more information becomes
available, I consider myself quite surprised. Definitely a blow that
the Tampa Bay Rays probably did not see coming. Looks like good bye Cooperstown, and hello retirement!
Then again, this might be another case of Manny being Manny.
A Family Tradition
Today there is a family tradition that I always partake in. It started about 19 years ago, when I got taken out of elementary school early to go to the Tigers home opener with my dad, brother and great uncle. Even though I have season tickets now, and have the opportunity to go to opening day, I instead chose to sell my tickets so I could stay at home and watch the game with my family.
Call me crazy, but this is one family tradition that I’m not willing to let go of. That, and the line to the bathroom is significantly shorter.
Which Young Gun Is Your Number One?
As I was listening to the Tigers game on the radio today, I found myself contemplating a hypothetical situation. Imagine that all of Major League Baseball had disbanded, and there was going to be a new draft with all current players available. You have the first pick in the draft, but you have to pick between the following players: Justin Verlander, Felix Hernandez, Josh Johnson, Zach Greinke, Stephen Strasburg or Tim Lincecum. For the sake of argument, their salary is not a factor. Which young gun would you select to be the ace of your franchise?
My rankings are as follows…
1. Justin Verlander-Without a doubt, Verlander has proven that he deserves to be the ace of the Tigers rotation which has been in constant contention since his rookie year in 2006 in which he got his first (and only taste) of the postseason. He has proven to be durable, has big game experience, and seems to be a likable person within the organization. Although my number two selection comes close, I give Verlander the edge due to playoff experience and his no hitter.
2. Felix Hernandez-Unquestionably a force to be reckoned with, Hernandez should find himself to be a constant Cy Young candidate for as long as he can stay healthy. It’s hard to imagine that Hernandez will spend his entire career in Seattle, where he would have had plenty more wins if he had more run support. Don’t get me wrong, I don’t think you’d be wrong picking King Felix, but I don’t think he’s had enough ‘big game’ experience yet.
3. Tim Lincecum-Maybe the hardest pick for me was putting Lincecum at number three, but it’s due to a couple issues. The first is that although he is unquestionably talented, I’d be very curious how his numbers would look if he pitched in the American League. With two Cy Young awards and a World Series ring, you could make a strong argument that he should be either number two or one on this list, and I would no doubt have a hard time to discredit that. However, for the sake of debate, I would rather have Verlander or Hernandez before him. Lincecum is also only entering his fifth year in Major League Baseball, so I’d like someone with a little more experience.
4. Josh Johnson-Not sure how you can’t like what you see with Johnson. He’s big, and he throws hard. Similar to Hernandez, you wonder what his numbers would be like if he played for a legitimate contender, but even without that, his numbers have been impressive so far. I would pick him higher, but I’d like him to have another year or two under his belt before I’d consider him before Verlander or Hernandez.
5. Stephen Strasburg-Strasburg lived up to expectations in his brief stint with the Nationals in 2010, but obvious health concerns make selecting him difficult. If he can prove he can get back to even 90 percent of what he was before Tommy John surgery, Strasburg should have no problem dominating lineups for years to come.
6. Zach Greinke-Despite his success, I think Greinke has still flown relatively under the radar. Depending where this fantasy franchise would be based out of, I’d be more likely to take him in a smaller market team. It would be very interesting to see how Greinke would do playing for a team like the Yankees or Red Sox, but then again I think all of these pitchers would get a few extra wins each year playing for either of those teams.
Don’t get me wrong, it’d be hard to turn down any of these players with the first pick, as a strong case could be made for all of them. Thankfully I don’t think I’ll have to ever worry about making a decision like this in my lifetime.
Take Me Out to the Ball Game
So while driving to work today, I was listening to the radio, and came up with an interesting question I wanted to ask everyone out there in baseball land. Is there a song (or songs) that you automatically just associate with baseball? For me, any time I hear this song, it brings me back to being a kid at Tigers stadium.
What songs would you put on your baseball play list?

Recent Comments